Balanced governance values all that matters

Governance should enable opportunity as well as mitigate risk. It’s about more than applying the brakes. Lessons from Formula 1 and a global CEO on protecting value and creating it.

17 November 2026
Balanced stones symbolising effective corporate governance, balancing risk management with growth and long-term value creation

In brief


  • Good governance protects existing value and enables future value. Yet growing demands for risk management, compliance and oversight can consume leadership capacity needed for strategy, innovation and growth. With productivity growth slowing across advanced economies, achieving the right balance matters more than ever.


  • Protecting value and creating it are two sides of the same coin. Drawing on international research, Formula 1 and firsthand global leadership experience, this Perspective explores how boards and CEOs can strengthen governance effectiveness, protect leadership capacity and cultivate the ambition, judgement and accountability needed to deliver sustainable results.

_       _       _       _       _       _       _       _       _       _


Across four decades of international business leadership and two decades of governance experience, I have observed very different approaches to balancing rigorous oversight with strategic and commercial ambition. The challenge is ensuring governance protects existing value while enabling future opportunities.


📊 The growing weight of governance


Boards and directors face expanding regulatory obligations, stakeholder expectations and emerging risks, often requiring additional information, assurance and oversight. Each requirement may be justified individually, yet their cumulative effect on leadership capacity and attention can evolve without deliberate assessment.


Recent global research by Spencer Stuart, drawing on 1,424 directors, chairs and CEOs, reinforces both the challenge and the opportunity. Its findings associate more dynamic, forward-looking boards with stronger reported business performance and greater CEO effectiveness. Its highest-performing archetype, Pacesetter boards, combines rigorous oversight with high trust, constructive challenge, strategic partnership and timely decision-making. The distinction is not between more or less governance, but between governance activity and its contribution to outcomes.


A 2025 Australian Institute of Company Directors (AICD) and Mandala Partners study reported indicative figures suggesting increased board attention devoted to risk and compliance: 24% in 2015 and 55% in 2025.


The measures are not directly comparable, but they raise an important question: how deliberately do boards allocate attention across risk, compliance, strategy, customers, investment and growth?

Cybersecurity, artificial intelligence, sustainability, psychosocial wellbeing and geopolitical tensions bring legitimate new responsibilities. Boards need the collective expertise to address these risks while maintaining sufficient commercial, operational, customer and growth experience to pursue future opportunities.


The balance will differ across organisations and jurisdictions. Effective delegation to board committees and management, supported by strong risk capabilities and technology, can limit unnecessary demands on the full board. The question is whether governance arrangements collectively deliver effective oversight without consuming disproportionate leadership capacity.


"The allocation of board time is itself a strategic decision. It should be made as deliberately as the allocation of capital."


Research from governance bodies in the United States and Ireland points to expanding board agendas, increasing governance complexity and growing demands on directors' time. The US National Association of Corporate Directors reported in 2025 that 74% of directors had experienced an increase in board agenda topics, while one-third found it harder to focus on critical business priorities. Research from the Institute of Directors Ireland similarly highlights escalating workloads and increasing regulatory demands on boards.

The AICD study estimated annual compliance costs associated with Australian Commonwealth regulation at approximately $160 billion in 2024, or 5.8% of GDP, compared with $65 billion and 4.2% in 2013. Separate OECD research identifies material compliance-related labour costs across several developed economies. Although the measures differ, both highlight the importance of weighing regulation’s economic and social benefits against its cumulative costs and potential consequences for productivity, innovation and growth.

Danielle Wood, Chair of Australia's Productivity Commission, reinforced these concerns at The Australian Financial Review's
 Chanticleer Lunch in Sydney on 23 September 2026. Reflecting on the growing proportion of board time devoted to risk and compliance, she observed:


“That is time that’s not spent on strategy, on investment, workforce – all of those key questions.”


She then raised a more fundamental question about the psychology of risk-focused governance, asking whether it had made Australia’s broader business culture too conservative or risk-averse.


This is not uniquely an Australian challenge. In its December 2025 Economic Outlook, the OECD examined how cumulative regulatory burdens can constrain productivity and economic dynamism across advanced economies, associating higher compliance costs with lower labour productivity, reduced business formation and weaker incentives for innovation.


"The question is not simply what regulation costs, but what economic value may never be created as a consequence."


⏳ The economic value of leadership time


Board and executive attention is finite. Effective oversight encompasses strategy, innovation, investment and growth alongside risk management and compliance. The concern arises when excessive reporting, duplicated assurance, unnecessary meetings and other low-value governance activity consume leadership capacity without commensurate improvements in organisational outcomes.


Risk management and compliance demand analytical discipline, sound judgement and attention to vulnerabilities and obligations. Strategy, innovation and growth also require imagination, curiosity, commercial judgement and the courage to challenge established assumptions. Both are essential to effective governance.


Many risk and compliance obligations are scheduled and mandatory. Strategic exploration requires deliberate attention and room to experiment, not merely whatever time remains.


What occupies leadership time also signals to an organisation what matters. When governance dominates calendars, demonstrating oversight can appear more important than creating future value, strengthening customer relationships and building trust. These signals shape organisational priorities, behaviours and culture, potentially diminishing outcomes for customers, shareholders, members and other beneficiaries.


"How leaders allocate their time matters twice: through the opportunities they pursue or forgo, and through the priorities they signal to their organisations."


📈 The compounding economics of opportunity


Consider an illustrative business generating $1 billion in annual revenue at a 15% EBIT margin. If revenue grows at 6% annually rather than 5%, just one percentage point faster, while operating expenses grow at 4%, EBIT after seven years is approximately 33% higher ($386 million compared with $289 million).


The significance lies in the economic consequences of opportunities never pursued or insufficiently supported.


This is an illustration, not a forecast. Faster growth requires effective execution, appropriate investment and disciplined risk management. The governance question is whether leadership has the capacity, confidence and support to identify, evaluate and pursue opportunities capable of delivering these outcomes.


⚖️ Rebalancing governance around outcomes


Governance is judged asymmetrically. When something goes wrong, boards and regulators face immediate scrutiny: Where was the board? What did it do? How did it hold management accountable? Opportunities never explored, investments deferred and value never created attract far less attention, despite potentially substantial economic consequences.


This asymmetry can also influence leadership mindset. Boards and executives rightly devote considerable attention to managing existing and emerging risks. But is comparable attention given to identifying and pursuing opportunities for innovation, growth and value creation?


Rebalancing governance is not about diminishing oversight or reducing attention to material risks. It is about ensuring governance arrangements are proportionate, effective and aligned with the full range of organisational outcomes, including strategy, customers, innovation, investment, growth and financial performance. This requires both sound governance design and a leadership mindset which values protecting existing value and creating future value.


Regulatory expectations, litigation and the prospect of retrospective scrutiny influence board decisions. Boards understandably seek to demonstrate vulnerabilities were identified and addressed. But additional processes, documentation and assurance can become designed as much to withstand scrutiny as to improve risk outcomes.


"The result can be governance increasingly designed to be demonstrably defensible rather than demonstrably effective."


These concerns were echoed by outgoing Macquarie Group CEO, Shemara Wikramanayake, in a November 2026 interview with The Australian Financial Review. Reflecting on Australia’s approach to regulation and opportunity, she observed:


“Our pendulum has swung to downside protection because we’re comfortable, we’re trying to protect that, and I think regulation reflects that here.”


🏛️ The responsibility of regulators


Balanced governance is not solely the responsibility of boards and executives. Regulators also shape how organisations allocate leadership capacity, capital and resources through their supervisory priorities, enquiries and interventions.


Financial safety, market integrity and consumer protection are essential, but they are not the entirety of the public interest. Regulatory frameworks should also recognise the importance of efficient, competitive and well-functioning markets in which businesses can innovate, grow and create sustainable value for their owners and beneficiaries.


This calls for proportionate supervision which removes unnecessary duplication and complexity, strengthens risk management and market confidence, and considers both the risks addressed and the leadership capacity and opportunities potentially constrained.


"Effective supervision should protect against loss while enabling the conditions for greater future value creation."


As James Clear observes in Atomic Habits, “You do not rise to the level of your goals. You fall to the level of your systems.”


The same applies to governance. Strong risk management capabilities, supported by effective people, technology, decision rights and accountability, can improve risk outcomes while reducing unnecessary oversight and intervention.


A global CEO with whom I worked once described excessive assurance layers as “checkers checking the checkers.”


Effective oversight depends on risk ownership, sound decisions, appropriate controls and organisational culture, not simply the volume of reporting or assurance.


"More checking does not necessarily mean more effective assurance."


🛠️ A practical leadership discipline


Rather than introduce another governance framework, boards and executive teams can adopt a straightforward three-step discipline.


1. 🔍 Assess | Understand where leadership capacity goes


Map: Examine how board and executive time is allocated across risk, compliance, strategy, customers, innovation and growth

Challenge: Identify duplication, unnecessary oversight and activities which add little value, distinguishing mandatory requirements from internal choices

Question: What opportunities are being displaced, and is governance demonstrably improving risk outcomes?


2. ⚖️ Rebalance | Strengthen protection and enable opportunity


Simplify: Remove low-value activity, clarify decision rights and strengthen risk ownership and capabilities

Prioritise: Protect leadership time for strategy, customers and growth. Agree where to invest, which opportunities to pursue and the risks the organisation is prepared to take

Lead: Cultivate ambition, curiosity and considered risk-taking. Encourage constructive challenge, back capable leaders, make timely decisions and learn from setbacks without compromising accountability.


3. 📈 Evaluate and adjust | Measure outcomes, not activity


Review: Assess risk effectiveness, decision speed, leadership capacity and progress against strategic priorities

Measure: Evaluate customer outcomes, innovation, growth, financial performance and long-term value creation

Adapt: Refine governance arrangements and leadership priorities as circumstances evolve.


The test is demonstrably better outcomes across both value protection and creation, without adding another governance layer.


🏎️ The leadership choice


The Board Chair and CEO, informed by the General Counsel, Company Secretary and wider executive team, have a particular responsibility to establish the balance between protecting existing value and creating future value, rather than allow it to evolve by default.


Boards and executives signal priorities through the questions they ask, time they allocate, investments they approve and achievements they recognise. These choices shape organisational culture and reinforce what matters, from risk management and customer trust to innovation, growth and long-term value creation. Ultimately, leadership must be accountable for results, not activity alone.


Like a Formula 1 driver, effective leaders need the judgement to massage the accelerator and modulate the brake, applying each with precision as circumstances demand.


Strong governance should give leaders the confidence to accelerate, not merely the means to apply the brakes.


"Balanced governance is ultimately a leadership choice: the deliberate pursuit of an organisation's capacity to protect value and create it."


🎯 Valuing all that matters


Dan, a former global CEO with whom I worked and whose leadership delivered an exceptional record of sustained growth and value creation, often reminded his leadership team: “We are our results.”


For Dan, this was a philosophy of personal accountability and relentless improvement, extending well beyond financial performance to strategic progress, customer outcomes, colleague engagement, culture, risk management, reputation, shareholder returns and contributions to the wider community.


The most effective balance I have witnessed between rigorous risk management and ambitious strategic and commercial leadership was achieved through an integrated operating system built on empowerment, accountability, transparency and visibility.


Across a large, complex global enterprise operating in numerous countries and spanning multiple businesses and service lines, operating leaders were empowered to pursue opportunities and held accountable for results. Compliance was mandatory, regulatory obligations non-negotiable and holistic risk assessment integral to significant decisions. Delegations of authority were clearly defined, documented and monitored.


This operating discipline was reinforced by Dan’s relentless emphasis on ambition and accountability. He would remind us “complacency is a cancer” and “even when the ball’s not in our court, the ball’s in our court.” His message was unmistakable: effective leaders continually seek opportunities to improve performance and create value, taking responsibility for influencing outcomes rather than accepting circumstances as constraints.


Another of Dan's expressions resonated deeply with me, and I enthusiastically adopted it with my own global teams: “Our potential is only limited by our imagination, capability and will.”


But imagination needs more than ambition. It requires time and an organisational environment which encourages curiosity, reflection, exploration and the freedom to challenge conventional thinking.


Meaningful breakthroughs rarely emerge from simply refining established practices. Sometimes they demand the courage to challenge the operating model itself, to rethink how value is created, disrupt established assumptions and pursue possibilities beyond the organisation's existing boundaries.


Effective governance should enable this courage, not unintentionally reward conformity at the expense of innovation and growth.


Together, Dan's philosophies capture two essential dimensions of leadership: the ambition to realise an organisation's potential, and the accountability to deliver results. Neither is sufficient without the other.


Good governance should strengthen outcomes for all beneficiaries by managing the risk of loss while enabling future value creation.


"Governance should create the confidence, capacity and conditions for imagination, capability and will to translate into meaningful results, not inadvertently constrain the potential of those it exists to serve."



Sources -

  1. Spencer Stuart (2026), Unlocking the Dynamic Board Advantage. Global Board and CEO Advisory research, survey of 1,424 respondents.
  2. Australian Institute of Company Directors and Mandala Partners (2025), The economic cost of regulatory complexity. Board attention to risk and compliance; estimated costs of Australian Commonwealth (federal) regulation. The 2015 and 2025 board-attention figures are indicative because the underlying survey questions differed.
  3. OECD (2026), OECD Compendium of Productivity Indicators 2026, Chapter 2: Labour productivity in OECD economies. Long-term trends in median annual labour productivity growth across OECD countries.
  4. National Association of Corporate Directors (2025), Preparing for Five Crucial Board Balancing Acts in 2025. Expanding board agendas and competing demands on directors' attention.
  5. Institute of Directors Ireland (2025), Board Director Remuneration and Governance Survey 2025/26. Increasing governance complexity, regulatory demands and workloads affecting boards and directors.
  6. Andrews, D., Turban, S. and Tyros, S. (2026), Regulatory compliance costs and productivity: New task-based evidence, OECD Economics Department Working Papers, No. 1856. Comparative evidence on compliance-related labour costs and productivity in Australia, the United States and selected European economies. Measures are not directly comparable with the AICD's estimates of total compliance costs as a percentage of GDP.
  7. Kehoe, J. and Lagan, G. (23 September 2026), Declining trust and ‘grey corruption’ stalling reform: PC boss, The Australian Financial Review. Productivity Commission Chair Danielle Wood's observations on board time, strategy, investment and risk aversion.
  8. OECD (December 2025), OECD Economic Outlook, Volume 2025 Issue 2: Resilient Growth but with Increasing Fragilities, Chapter 2, “Time for a Regulatory Reset?” Regulatory complexity, compliance burdens, productivity, innovation and economic dynamism.
  9. Macdonald, A. (6 November 2026), Macquarie’s departing CEO warns ‘comfort’ risks Australia’s future, The Australian Financial Review. Interview with Shemara Wikramanayake on the balance between downside protection, regulation and future opportunity.
  10. Clear, J. (2018), Atomic Habits: An Easy & Proven Way to Build Good Habits & Break Bad Ones. Author's original quotation concerning goals and systems.
  11. Australian Prudential Regulation Authority, About APRA, and Australian Securities and Investments Commission, Our role. Statutory responsibilities and objectives concerning financial safety, financial system stability, efficiency, competition, market integrity and consumer protection.


Additional perspective: The observations and quotations attributed to Dan are drawn from the author's firsthand professional experience and were reviewed by him. The financial illustration is hypothetical, based on the assumptions outlined in the article, and is not a forecast.

Clarity. Focus. Growth.

For the decisions that shape value.


🌐 rivalstreet.com


This Perspective is provided by Rival Street for general information only. It reflects observations on business strategy, growth, operating performance and value creation and does not constitute financial product, investment, legal, tax or other professional advice. It does not take into account the objectives, financial situation or needs of any person. Please refer to our Terms of Use.

Magnifying glass bringing detail into focus, representing how businesses can identify opportunities.
18 August 2026
Rival Street explores how businesses can outperform by treating the plan as a commitment, allocating capital to opportunity and empowering people to create upside.
An intersection representing investment choices, private equity strategy and value creation.
21 May 2026
Rival Street explores how private equity value creation is shifting towards operational execution, customer economics and disciplined growth under ownership.
Two hands reaching towards each other, representing customer trust, relationships & long-term value.
29 April 2026
Rival Street explores customer trust as an economic asset that can strengthen retention, pricing resilience, lifetime value and sustainable growth.